
TL;DR
- Faster contract turnaround keeps legal stuck in the queue.
- Let the business handle low-risk deals and decisions that aren't legal ones.
- Make self-service the default, with short "never" lists and mini playbooks.
- Use AI to add capacity, but keep a lawyer's judgment on what it produces.
- Track capacity, not just volume, and reach out early to earn a seat at the table.
In-house legal teams that get good at contracts often get rewarded with more contracts. The faster legal turns paper around, the more the business sees it as a processing function, and the less it involves legal in the decisions that create that paper in the first place.
That was the focus of The Fulfillment Trap: Moving In-House Legal from Contract Queue to Strategic Partner, an In-House Connect webinar sponsored by SpotDraft. Akshay Verma, Chief Operating Officer at SpotDraft, moderated a panel of three practitioners:
- Sean Coberly, Senior Vice President & General Counsel, Tendo
- Alexis Palmer, Senior Managing Counsel, Snyk
- Jonathan Stark, Head of Legal Operations, Dynatrace
The audience recognised the problem. In a live poll, 35% said strategic work happens "around the edges", and 36% said they actively protect time for it. Here's what the panel said it takes to get out of the queue.
1. Fast service sets a higher bar
Sean described the trap from his own desk. His team's official SLA for returning a contract was seven days. He usually turned them around in one or two, so the business started treating one day as the real SLA.
The rest of a GC's work doesn't help, because much of it is confidential. "I go to our senior leadership meetings every week, and everybody goes through, 'What did you do this week?' And I'm like, 'I did stuff.'" People who can't see the HR, financing or regulatory work assume legal has nothing else on its plate. Meanwhile the projects that would make the biggest difference keep slipping to next quarter.
The takeaway: Speed alone won't earn legal a strategic role. Without deliberate changes, it just raises expectations for the queue.
2. Decide what doesn't need a lawyer
Hiring more lawyers is rarely an option, so the panel focused on taking work out of the queue instead. Jonathan's first lever is to let sales handle low-value, low-risk agreements with a good playbook and a fallback guide. Legal then keeps its time for higher-value, higher-risk deals.
Sean draws a firm line between legal decisions and business decisions. For a vendor renewal that's "the same as last year with a 2% bump", he tells the team: "That's a business decision. You don't need to ask me to review business decisions." He'll happily join a customer call about termination for convenience, but not about pricing or discounts. His contract structure helps: the business owns the order form and SOW, and legal owns the MSA.
Old habits persist. In a poll, 14% of attendees said the business still expects legal to review everything. Alexis remembered a sales ops colleague asking why a lawyer wouldn't review standard template contracts. Her answer was to lock the template so nobody could change it, and to lean on a growing deal desk-style sales ops team as it built up.
The takeaway: Write down which decisions belong to the business, and hold that line, politely, every time.
3. Rethink the playbook
Playbooks are the standard tool for empowering the business, but Alexis has "really strong feelings" about highly prescriptive ones. Unless your company has the leverage to say no to everything, too much of negotiation lives in "it depends."
She prefers a lighter structure:
- A short "never" list. Terms you won't accept without CFO-level sign-off, "and even then maybe not."
- Preferred and non-preferred positions. Buckets that guide judgment rather than replace it.
- Mini playbooks for specific checks. Run this section against the background check policy, that one against support requirements, another against insurance.
The mini playbooks also work better with AI. Asking a tool to pre-mark a 55-page MSA against one big playbook gives "an okay result." Small, targeted prompts let her check the work as she goes.
The takeaway: Use the playbook to record your non-negotiables, and keep the judgment calls in small, focused checks.
4. Teach the business to fish
Sean had a fresh example. On a flight that morning, six people messaged him about a question the contract answered in one clause. The contract was attached to the account in Salesforce. His explanation was blunt: "It's easier to write an email, so you can say that you're waiting on somebody else."
The panel admitted legal makes this worse when it answers just to clear the request. Now they redirect instead. Jonathan reminds colleagues to ask Slackbot or check the system of record. Alexis says she'd have to search for it herself, and asks whether they'd like to try first.
Self-service needs somewhere fast to go when people get stuck. Jonathan's team runs dedicated Slack channels, such as one for AI-clause questions, which legal monitors and answers quickly. "The worst thing is submitting something to a queue and it becomes a black hole." Alexis treats training as a conversation opener, then turns the material into an AI skill that answers questions about the CLM. Eventually she plans to give it to the business directly.
The takeaway: Every time you answer a question the business could have answered itself, you're training it to keep asking.
5. Use AI to scale, but keep the judgment
Sean was direct about headcount. "If I didn't have AI… we would have to have hired another attorney." He built an internal contract redliner trained on more than 10,000 of his company's contracts, including every redline, decision and note he had made. It suggests how his team usually handles each clause.
He is just as direct about the limits. Of 10,000 contracts, roughly 1,000 will have something the model can't read or interpret, and he plans to bring in interns for those. His rule for the tool: "Don't tell me a fact unless you can point me to an article, a law review, or whatever that I can open up myself." For an experienced lawyer, he said, AI is "one of the greatest things ever" for doing more with less, as long as you "marry that experience and education with a tool as opposed to relying on it."
The other panellists use AI in similar ways:
- Jonathan built an agent loaded with his outside counsel guidelines. It flags anything non-compliant in an engagement letter, so he only takes exceptions to an attorney.
- Alexis uses AI to draft a first pass at SOW language from public product documentation. Then she asks the stakeholder to genuinely confirm it, "not just sort of a sign-off."
The takeaway: AI creates capacity when experienced people use it to check their own judgment. It doesn't replace that judgment.
6. Measure capacity, not just activity
At Amazon, Jonathan had dashboards tracking how long a contract sat with each person, and he now thinks it was "too much data." At Dynatrace he tracks a few basics: the value of each deal and who on the legal team owns it. His current CLM didn't capture this, so he built a deal tracker in Asana.
The goal is to see whether people have too much work, not to push more onto them. "Is Big Brother watching me?" was the first reaction, he admitted. But the data made the case for a commercial legal centre of excellence. Certain agreement types now go to contract managers and legal specialists instead of attorneys.
The team also logs its AI use every Friday, by tool and by task: redlining, drafting or summarising. Those data points now shape what Jonathan wants from his next CLM, including agents that pick up an agreement from Salesforce and do a first-pass review against the playbook.
Value can be measured as well as workload. After Dynatrace published standard AI and security policies for vendors, manually negotiated AI addenda fell from about 200 last year to around 10.
The takeaway: Track the metrics that show capacity and outcomes, not just volume. That data justifies redesigning the team and shows legal's value.
7. Earn the seat at the table
Freeing up time is only half the job. Legal still has to get involved before deals, launches and budgets are set. "Folks don't tend to come to you," Alexis said. Her answer is proactive outreach:
- Monthly and quarterly meetings with key stakeholders
- Ten-minute calls instead of long Slack threads. "I'd rather give you 10 minutes than you spend 30 minutes or an hour" on something legal will have to fix anyway.
- Active participation in deal and account Slack channels, sharing what legal has seen across other customers and deals, not only legal points
Sean earned his place by changing what legal is known for. "My goal is to never say no, it's let's find a better way to do this." Now his leadership team asks legal for risk mitigations as soon as a strategic idea takes shape. When a team skips that step, the result makes the point for him.
One team built a product for six months, then showed it to him, and it turned out the company was contractually barred from doing it. His lesson: "Five minutes of questions can save you six months of work."
The takeaway: A strategic role comes from trust built one conversation at a time. Teams that show legal's value get invited in earlier.
Want to see how other legal teams are making this shift? Read SpotDraft's State of Legal Operations Report.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the “fulfillment trap” for in-house legal teams?
How can in-house legal teams reduce contract volume without increasing risk?
How can legal teams use AI to create capacity?
Related content



